IT’S IN THE BAG – OR IS IT?
YOU may realise that in Wales a charge of 5p is being made on shopping bags (“one off bags” supplied in retail outlets, big and small as from the 1st October.
It has been decided that the profits from the sale of these bags will go to local charity causes. Also there will be policing of the charge by a team of mystery shoppers.
All this sounds fairly okay at first glance until you realise what is happening behind it. Instead of levying the charge at the needle end bag issue – the wholesaler, they have gone for the haystack end – the shops.
Realising that there are circumstances where the supply of a bag is necessary some exemptions are available. (For health reasons in the case of medicines or to separate harmful substances from food for example, or practicality – loose vegetables is allowable)
Now, you can feel the civil servants champing at the administrative bit and rubbing their hands. The moment a bag of loose fruit and vegetables has a non exempt item placed in it – let’s say a box of Oxo Cubes then it loses exemption and 5p must be paid.
There are fines for shops not keeping to the rules. All shops and retail outlets are involved. Separate accounts must be kept of the 5p income so that the shop knows how much it can give to charity, as it has to do from the levy. However the cost of administration can be deducted.
In effect a separate small business for bags, with full accounting and admin has to run alongside. Presumably accounts will have to be filed and therefore checked centrally or published in some way. Presumably managers will be needed to manage the mystery shoppers and report in.
Each shop will have to allocate staff to handle the admin and accounts and to canvass opinion on the charity and actually make the payments.
Don’t think you will get away with it if you are outside Wales – England and Scotland are at advanced stages of following suit with their own schemes. No doubt they will be different in detail. Shops that happen to straddle a border will no doubt have different rules at one end of the shop from the other.
Our vegetable man, who comes round once a week in his van sells a mixture of loose vegetables, which are exempt and bagged vegetables – which are not. If you haven’t got your own bag he gives you a second hand one from a supply he has. Oh dear….!
Bob Shepherd




